Just as he doesn't care whether she's human or not, he doesn't much care whether or not she believes him. He'll let his actions speak louder than words in that department, if given the opportunity. Right now, it seems prudent to move onto more important aspects of the conversation, now that he's cleared up what he meant.

She's right, of course, but 76 doesn't come around so easily when Reaper is involved. It's far too personal--something that simply cuts too deep and colors everything else in the process.

"Obviously not the kind of criminal I'm talking about."